Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-5984859-20150717140732/@comment-26509603-20150731185454

AwfulFatso wrote: I know I’m late to respond, but Magic is not an element due to the reason that anyone can do it. Magic requires a spell chant that is located in the Book of Spells. Therefore to perform the anciet Art of Magic, you just read a spell and there is no descendant from the Elemental Master of Magic because there is no Magic Master.

Well, you raise valid points except for the last one. There is no proof that there was never a Master of Magic, and therefore a decendent of them.

In addition, technically, Clouse was the only one able to recite spells without the book. Isn't it possible that he was making them up himself? If Amber is an element (which is copying and using other elements), I don't see why Magic can't be one.